Eddie Martini's - Steak house in Wauwatosa - 8612 W Watertown Plank Rd, USA

We haven't been to Eddie Martini's in years. We got one of their last reservations on a Saturday to celebrate my mom's birthday. We started with the Stewed Escargot and Grilled Brie. Both were delicious. Everyone's dinner was amazing. I had the Pomegranate Miso- Glazed Salmon, and it was really good. Then it was time for dessert. The birthday dessert is a Chocolate Flourless Cake with Fresh Whipped Cream. So yummy. We also had Chocolate Cake with Vanilla Ice Cream. But the best dessert hands down was their Bread Pudding with Homemade Cinnamon Ice Cream. Unbelievable! Our servers were Sara and Hannah, and they were both excellent!

Eddie Martini’s is exactly everything I wanted and asked for in a restaurant. It's truly a one-of-a-kind dining experience with a flavorful a la carte and a great birthday location if your looking as well! This is my second time here and it was even greater than before! It's a high referral from myself! Great staff from the host to the servers! Incredible!!!!

We had a marvelous time at the restaurant with the great food and great service. Enjoyed the evening dining at the restaurant. Thanks Mara for the kind hospitality!

Service is beyond description. The host he was very charming and remembered the reason we were dining (birthday) and congratulated right away and was so accommodating to make our visit so special. That was just the half. The meal we ordered was wagyu steak medium. PERFECTLY done. Melted like butter. Another we ordered was 45-day dry aged strip medium. Unfortunately it was done too well which they immediately corrected. The whole experience was platinum! The environment I rated as a 4 because the tables were too close together in the Club dining area such that you had to be very careful getting in and out of your seat. Otherwise, the experience and the service of the staff was beyond expectations!

My first time at Eddie Martini’s and I could not have had a better meal. Started with hot spinach salad which was amazing. It could have been a meal all on its own. Followed up with the Roasted duck. My wife had the most succulent petite filet. The service was impeccable. The drinks were great. All in all this was a five star meal and I can’t wait to go back again.

We came for our anniversary and were met with the strangest dining experience. I ordered a Manhattan and was given a glass that was half vermouth and half of a cheap bourbon. I found this odd because I usually have a Manhattan that just had a splash of sweet vermouth. When I told the bartender that I did not like the drink I was met with apprehension. Then, we ordered the lobster bisque and it tasted like burnt nuts. The steak was flavorless and the sauce tasted burnt just like the bisque. I paid $177 for a meal that tasted like burnt mess. The manager was made aware of my experience and I was still asked to pay the full amount for such a bad anniversary dinner. To make matters worse, the manager and the wait staff were talking about me in their little nook by the bar. It didn’t help that they would make eye contact with me as they spoke poorly of me 😔

On a whim my father suggested we go here. At 5:10 on a Monday night we got the last available table, so plan ahead! The food and drinks were fantastic - as a long time martini aficionado I ordered the Eddie Martini and it was exquisite. The lobster bisque was outstanding, and the filet mignon was divine. There's no official dress code but most customers were in business casual or better. The service was excellent (despite our lack of style), and if you're looking for something special we highly recommend it.

The benchmark for fine dining in the Wauwatosa area, Eddie Martini's always delivers an incredible experience. The service is refined, the drinks are terrific, and the food is divine. Those in the mood for top notch steak need look no further than Eddie Martini's, but be sure to also try their seafood. The seafood pasta is especially decadent.