East Hampton Grill - American restaurant in East Hampton - 99 N Main St, USA

I love the most amazing scallop salad and the prime rib. They were not serving them this time I was there. I do not like the sweet sauce and char of the broiled ribeye. I appreciate them replacing it with fillet with less char and no sauce. It is much better and good service I love the dining room atmosphere Lack of quality desert variety makes me having no desert here

5 stars because all of the food was such high quality and super fresh. Ambiance is lovely with nice spacing between tables so you don't feel squished. Our server was delightful and attentive. Honestly my only complaint is the French fries are too thin and skinny so they are more like crunchy potato chips. Highly recommend the chilled jumbo shrimp and Caesar with crispy oysters! Also don't skip the biscuits, you'll thank me later :)

We were dining there yesterday and unfortunately were not happy with the food. My partner ordered a french dip and woke up next day to a upset stomach, I took a piece of the sandwich from him and also felt like something was off with the meat;( My tuna tatar was very blant and without any taste.. . Drinks were good though but we will definitively will not be back;(

Oh my gosh how decadent!! We ended up sitting at the bar, and the seats were surprisingly comfy. The food was out of this world. Definitely came with an out of this world price tag, but worth it if you’re looking for a snazzy night out. Get the biscuits & some to save for the morning after! Make sure you get a reservation way in advance — we could only get one for 8:45 (which was fine but later for us than expected). Overall, great vibes & scrumptious foods — we’ll be back :)

The food was amazing! I cannot communicate how necessary it is to try the heavenly biscuits and the deviled eggs. Fantastic service every time

Our server was really awesome! I forgot her name however she'll always be remembered in my memory. You're missing out if you don't order steak in this place, it was cooked to perfection, can't complain. They weren't busy so the wait time was 15 minutes for us. Also try their key lime pie!

One of our staple restaurants in East Hampton. During the cold season, it has a very cozy vibe with a giant fire place - perfect place to go to dinner with friends. We also love sitting at the bar for evenings when it’s just the two of us. My favorite menu items are the biscuits and deviled eggs for apps, and for entree the filet with bearnaise sauce or the lightly battered halibut with lemon sauce (usually on their specials menu).

Our waitress Tyler was great. Very kind and had helpful suggestions. Bar is nice with great top shelf options. I felt menu was small but I’m picky I guess.