DiMaggio's Pizza and Burgers - Pizza restaurant in Coloma - 6410 M-63, USA

Stopped for dinner. We were each going to order a plate of pasta, but our server recommended adding the best ever meatballs and perhaps going with a half order. Great suggestion. The meatballs were good although maybe a little overpromised, and a half order was just the right size unless you're a teenager or you want leftovers. They were quite busy, and our waitress even busier. She managed to get our order out in 20 minutes. We didn't get drinks refilled, which wasn't surprising given the busyness. Another downside of the busyness was the noise level. With no music whatsoever, it was almost painfully loud inside the dining room, and we had trouble hearing each other. Prices are very reasonable, and I would come back...if it's not busy.

Friendly service! Beware this is cash or check only. I stopped in here to see what the pizza was all about. The pizza was overall lacking flavor, but the crust was crispy. I ordered a special pizza(peppers, sausage, and mushrooms) I probably should have gotten a more simple pizza, and that may have been a better experience.

Food: 4/5 (simple and so delicious) Service: 5/5 (quick, attentive, intentional, and great with refilling water!) Atmosphere: 3/5 (a little dated, but clean.) DiMaggio's Pizza and Burgers will always be my space for good diner type food. I rode in looking for a good sandwich. 7 miles from Bemton Harbor, in Coloma, sits a beautiful place that has an old-school feel. I had to try it. The service is top-notch! There was one waitress that rocked the house. She was on top of her tasks and made sure she was intentionally to make sure you were served. There were no mistakes made. The atmosphere appeared to draw in seniors as the restaurant appeared dated. Although things were vintage, it worked for this restaurant! The menu stated they have been serving the community for over 66 years! So neat! They only forms of payment they take are cash and checks. The food is so delicious. The pizza looks incredible, but I had the double cheese Burger. It tasted homemade, and it was so delicious and juicy! Although they didn't have fries, the chips made for a nice touch. The food was simple but very delicious 😋! All in all, it's a great space for a lunch or family getaway.

DiMaggios Pizza and Burgers is a very pleasant place to eat. Cash and checks only - no credit cards. However, they do have an ATM. The restaurant is well appointed with electric outlets at the tables and bar stools. Service was attentive and friendly. Food a bit disappointing. My salad was iceberg lettuce and my dining companion enjoyed her pizza, but not her favorite. Parking a little limited but adequate. Throwback 80s video game a nice to

First time trying this place and it was really good! Love the crust the cheese and the toppings. Super close to Hagar Park as well

If you are driving down Red Arrow onto Blue Star Highway going into Coloma Michigan slow down and keep your eyes open. This little bar/restaurant is on the side of the road and if you blink you'll miss it. Great pizza and wonderful service. Clean atmosphere with tables and booths. Well worth the trip if you are in the St. Joe, Benton Harbor area.

I have not been in a while- used to come all the time, and thought I would get pizza and garlic cheese bread. I was VERY disappointed.. The pizza had no flavor was burnt and bottom was like card board, I love pizza sauce this pizza had it all one side-dont know what happened. And let's not forget the garlic cheese bread. I have NEVER had cheese bread like this at any pizza place- they took a sub bread cut it down the middle and sprinkled garlic powder on it and very little cheese. Never going back.!!! AND they only take cash, ---- shady. (Did not eat)

OK this place was a random stop on the way to Holland and I can tell ya it was a home run of a stop. Super nice, super clean and quick off the highway. I ordered a small sausage pizza and it came out absolutely perfect. I guess they do the cheese and sausage and crust home made and it was magnificent. I might actually stop for another one on the way back home. My wife had a meatball sub too which she really liked a whole lot. Had half the pizza for lunch and had the rest for left overs and it was just as good cold. A+. I wish they were closer to Chicago