Croxley's Ale House - Farmingdale - Sports bar in Farmingdale - 190 Main St, USA

This is a GREAT place to watch any sporting event. Definitely the home of Islander fans. They're very accommodating on putting on games for you, you just need to speak up and ask. Of course the wings are the star of the show here. But their other dishes like Burgers (Beef or Turkey). I've had their Skirt steak which is just as good as a Steak house. And though prices have jumped Post-Covid, this place has reasonable prices.

We were at a birthday party in the upstairs area. It was so small, and the tables pushed together so close you couldn't get in or out. Tje food was ok, but the staff were less than happy to be there. We never got a smile, a nice word, or any pleasantries. They looked miserable. I had to clean off the table with the kids' food, and when they finally saw me, they came over and took them out of my hands. Gee thanks. The food was ok. We had to take a liquor package, and the wine was awful. Even the beer selection was minimal. If allowed to just run a bar tab, they would have gotten as much money, and we would have been happier. Also, the loft is not handicap accessible and my elderly aunt could barely get up the stairs.

Awesome place to watch the games. The food is great especially the wings and the burgers and everyone working at Croxley is friendly. Matt at the bar is amazing! Only feedback for ownership is to improve the mens bathroom. That needs a full renovation. Keep up the great work Guys!

A friend and I have been going here every other week or so for almost 2 months after our volunteering shift. Jamal is our waiter and he remembers us and puts us at the same table and remembers the drinks and even what we like to eat and everybody is super nice and I love all the lights! Not overpriced- three dollar Tacos on Tuesday- food is good and so are the drinks! Great dirty martini!

First time eating here and the food was HORRIBLE! Arrived around 12:45 pm and the place was empty. My wife had a burger and it was dry and had no taste. The two Cokes we had tasted like seltzer, waiter replaced and took off the bill but was still the same. I had probably the worst wings I’ve ever had. The meat was kind of tough. It wasn’t red inside so it was cooked but maybe old or overcooked? I ended up getting sick to my stomach. Looks like a nice place but will never try again. Don’t want food poisoning again.

It's a very nice charming restaurant & alehouse in Farmingdale near the railroad. I attended a private party in the back. A very attractive space with a large bar... the staff was very attentive and the drinks were very good. the food was just so so otherwise all was terrific

I had the wings and one of their burgers. The bread on the burger seemed stale, the wings didn't have any taste. Unfortunately I did not take any pictures, because I was hungry when I went there and when the food arrived I just started eating. It actually says a lot because of the food was good I definitely would have took some pictures of what I had left 😁

It was just great. They were so accommodating as we showed up early from the services for our loved one. It was raining(of course) and they let us in anyway and allowed us time gather in a room that was going to be used for another more happy gathering before ours. Just nice people and we were so grateful for their kindness.