Cosimo's Italian Restaurant - Italian restaurant in Westfield - 118 E Broad St, USA

I was super underwhelmed which is disappointing because I had their catering at a birthday party and loved the food. We ordered takeout on a Friday night. The honey crispy calamari was soggy and the portions were so small. The bolognese sauce had flavor but was watery. Bread was hard.

They now charge a credit card fee for orders on top of their prices, which they also have been raising. Credit cards are a cost of doing business. What next, they are going to charge a fee for water and electricity? Here is yet another restaurant I won't be supporting.

I was referred here by a friend and she pretty much raved about everything but mainly the salad. So being that her and I share a love of good food her recommendations always leave me in want and ready to run but covid etc. Today I had an appointment about 15 minutes out from them and knew I'd be hungry lol so I planned on having this amazing salad for lunch. I asked my friend all the specifics on how and what to order and it was simple, Cesar Salad with Grilled Salmon. Ok cool! She advised I could get extra salmon as she had done a time or 2. I decided I would ask for extra dressing and croutons & garlic bread.... placed order, picked up. I was greeted by a tall guy with gorgeous eyes and killer smile..he was super accommodating and made sure I was super good before I left with all I needed. I got home and ate... CAN YOU SAY AMAZING & ONE OF IF NOT THE BEST CESAR SALAD I EVER HAD & the Salmon cooked to PERFECTION!! The Cesar Dressing....OFFICAL! & The croutons..seasoned and I think it's real bread......Oooooo Tasty little Treat it was!!! Thank You Cosimo's I'llllll BE BAACK!!!

We have been eating at Cosimo's since I was 18 months (shh I'm almost 40!!) We always have our family events here, from birthdays to baptisms to first communion which we just had there for my twins! It feels like family when we walk in and the food is so delicious even my picky children eat there!!! Thanks for making another special day for us!! Xoxox

Our server was non-attentive to my party of 4. Her attitude was borderline rude and very dismissive. To make matters worse, she added a 15% gratuity to our bill. When I called and asked a manager if this was a customary practice I was given a few different responses but was ultimately told that parties of 4 don’t typically get charged a gratuity but the server might have FELT that we (the customers) weren’t going to tip adequately or at all. I responded that although gratuities are not required, I was always taught to leave at least 20% in cash for the server and that was my intention. I guess this didn’t matter since we didn’t give the server the impression that we would leave an adequate amount. I can’t help but wonder what gave the server the impression that we wouldn’t tip adequately…. TIPS AT THE DISCRETION OF THE SERVER??? No thanks!

Really well worth it. Food was great. So was service.

Cosimos is adorable! The atmosphere is welcoming and the staff is friendly. Its a great local spot for a good meal anytime. While their salads and sandwiches are always a win, I also greatly enjoyed the Flounder Francese.

The food is very good. The people who work here are very nice. It’s a large yet cozy restaurant. There is a fireplace and the windows in front are great for people watching. The first time I went here I thought it was a pizzeria, but when you walk in, the restaurant is to the left. I’ve eaten in and recently had take out. Every experience here has been top notch. Reasonably priced and BYOB!