Castaways Pizza & Grill - Pizza restaurant in Conneaut - 877 Broad St, USA

Great little place close to the Lake. The server was SUPER friendly, and fast. Just NICE for a 1st visit dining alone! Will definitely be back with my group.

First it did not make it in the take out bag. It was nice they delivered it but was cold and nasty no sauce or cheese. Pick up order at 7:15 the delivery of missing sub showed up at 8:10. Didn't even give anything extra to make up for our very not happy experience. This is not what our experience usually is like.

My family stopped here around 8 pm on Friday and had a great dinner. Very fair pricing. The pizza was mega comforting, really good cheese and crust. It was even good as leftovers over the next two days. The wings were a delicious classic with the Buffalo sauce.

4.4 stars…what a lie… waited an hour for our food. Apparently they didn’t know how to make the pizza we ordered.? And forgot our fries. The food is good size portions (a lot for your money) but there’s no significant saying of “this is this place” not to mention the entire order was $58 when we ordered 3 items… the waitress (the only one) was nice and was trying her hardest. The rest of the workers were all jammed in the tiny kitchen talking. Also note if you sit down to eat you’re waiting a minimum of an hour. I’m not sure if they prioritize the orders that are picked up? Either way there was a line.

5 years ago that evening, Jim and I had a great time eating and talking about our day. The food was delicious 😋 we didn't have to wait long for our food and it was very comfortable dining in.

We are from Youngstown Ohio stopped in today as we were in town for the first time visiting a family member and the waitress was extremely nice the food was delicious(I got the Ruben 😋) and price was really fair for quality of food and service I'd go back again 😌😁

Very friendly environment at Castaways. Our waitress Lisa was fantastic, she is a very positive individual that makes you feel welcome. The calzone we had was great, with lots of delicious cheese with very bite. We ordered the 12 inch calzone for the two of us, which was large enough we had to take half of it home . Great prices, great food, great place.

We had high hopes for the pizza at Castaways (the menu was certainly more extensive than just pizza but that is what we were craving). We were impressed by the cute decor and overall cleanliness of the restaurant. They also have outdoor seating but it was very hot so we chose indoors. We could tell the waitress was busy; in fact it appeared that there was only one for the entire restaurant while we were there. We got our drinks and app in a timely manner and absolutely loved the Gouda mac and cheese bites that we ordered. Then we waited for our supreme pizza for probably 35+ minutes and when it came we were disappointed. Hardly any veggies on it, and one half of the pizza was quite dark while the other half was almost doughy. The sauce and crust tasted good but overall we were disappointed.