Brownstone Cafe - American restaurant in Middletown - 1 N Union St, USA

This old bank turned restaurant is a great place to eat and just marvel at the atmosphere, I wish I had remembered to take pictures, but I forgot as we were with friends and the food was so appetizing that I totally forgot. Only got a picture of the sign outside. We had 6 in our group, and everyone was pleasantly surprised at how good the food and service was! Hubby and I had the chicken pot pie, with the crust, it was very good! My friend and I had pickled beets, very good, nice warm dinner rolls, hubby got mild hot wings, he said about the best sauce he's ever had, there was chicken stir fry, fried Salisbury steak, a club sandwich and can't think of the other meal 😋 anyway, all very good. I got the brownstone cheesecake, which had a brownie bottom, regular cheesecake in the middle and a layer of almost like a chocolate mousse top and it was fabulous. The waitress was so nice and accommodating to us even as busy as she was. We went on a Sunday afternoon. We would all highly recommend and are looking forward to going back even though we live an hour away!

September 2022 Very cool old bank building converted into a restaurant with an extensive menu with decent prices. The chicken parm with linguine was good and the chicken was tender, although the sauce was a little watery but it had a nice, simple garlic tomato flavor to it. The chicken pot pie was excellent, very flaky golden crust with a side of delicious homemade mashed potatoes. Excellent, attentive service and great coffee, too. Such a wonderful find while passing through the area.

First off, this place is beatutiful! You can tell it has some type of history attached to this building. Im so glad they also have a parking lot! I had the steak and eggs. The steak was lacking a bit flavor but everything else was great! The servers are so nice and welcoming.

Enjoyed our dinner on a Thursday night. Large diverse selection and reasonable prices. Portions were tasty and huge. Staff was attentive. Look forward to returning to this family owned gem.

Everything about this place was extraordinary, food , service and atmosphere. Will definitely return !

It is wonderful to be there for brunch. The service is great and I love the decorations especially the railroad 🛤 model. It used to be a bank and right now it’s a pretty busy Cafe. They served breakfast until 11am. Really appreciate their services. The reason why I count one star off is because the medium steak 🥩 I ordered was cooked approximately well done. I didn’t want to complain since I know they were busy serving other guests. Hope next time they serve better cuisine so that I can give a five stars ⭐️ again! Love French toasts.

First time here. Menu has large variety of choices at very reasonable prices. Staff was very welcoming and super friendly. Food was off-the-charts good except french onion soup was disappointing. That's the only thing there was any fault with. I highly recommend going here for a great meal that bests most places.

Definitely old school dinner feel... good is so-so but lots of options. Service was great. Our young kids were allowed to explore (we keep an eye on them though so they weren't disturbing other customers), but cool they could move around.