Brothers Grim Games and Collectibles - Collectibles store in Selden - 1244 Middle Country Rd, USA

Great selection of DnD items and dice. Nice variety of Warhammer items. Paint and brushes. And I especially loved seeing my childhood games again.

I tried trading in a bunch of ps2 games for cash and I was completely let down and felt like I was taking advantage of he basically gave me nothing. I do not recommend this place to trade in games for cash. If you live in the area I highly recommend you much rather go to game on in miller place.

This place has been good to me since highschool (starting around 2008?) Even when i came home on leave, i made it a point to stop in and see the new merchandise, maybe sell some cards and pick some new stuff up! Definitely the best card shop i've been to on the island, and will definitely be continuing to recommend and visit for another 15 years.

So, this place has a fair selection of content to browse and buy. MTG, D&D, Warhammer -- there's a good bit to look at, but that's not the problem. Problem's how they treat customers and guests. I've gone with my friend group a couple of times, sometimes for MTG tournaments or buying minis, and while the staff aren't very helpful in general, they're pretty unfriendly to new players. On top of that, the store and staff are not welcoming to women. Like, at all. It's almost creepy levels of misogyny; the place itself, the staff, and a fair bit of their community too. It's sad because it's now the nearest open game store to us, but as a group, we'd really rather not go back.

Place is ok. Alot of everything for everyone. Went to bring my yugioh for evaluation and price. Wwwaayyyy too low then I'm expecting. Know the worth of them and not close to what I'm expecting. Beside that it's an ok store just don't know how I feel about selling my cards there.

What a great place for all things nerdy and niche interest. You can find Dungeons & Dragons merch, collectible video game merch, and playing cards from all the popular TTPCGs like Yu-Gi-Oh and Magic The Gathering. They have a great collection of D&D minis for purchase, both painted and unpainted! They've even got dice made of actual rare stone! They have entire sections dedicated to card games, D&D books, and video games respectively. Trust me you'll find what you're looking for here. Furthermore they have tables for people to hangout and play whatever card games they are into and also tables for people to play their preferred TTRPGs. You can even attend TTPCG tournaments and TTRPG games that are open to people to sign up for. Just ask the staff! The staff is really knowledgeable about everything they have in the store so you can be sure they can give you the info you need. Great store with a lot of great merch and friendly staff!

Place looks nice but maybe you shouldn’t claim you buy pokemon cards if you only buy rare cards and turn away people just selling their cards

The first time I went there like a few years ago, I remembered the place was crowded at night. I had no idea, and just left. The second time I went, I bought a set of Vocaloid cards (upper right corner)because it was my favorite fandom. This time, I came back again to buy single Pokemon tcg cards and a Hatsune Miku card sleeves (upper left corner). There were some good stuff if you're into Pokemon and anime. I'm more likely to come back again if I feel the mood to collect more cards.