Brooklyn Pizza - Grill - Pizza restaurant in Lancaster - 1750 Oregon Pike, USA

My husband brought me a grandmas pie pizza and a regular cheese pie to have ready after I gave birth at the nearby birthing hospital and pizza was amazing!!! Even ate it cold the next day and had the same great flavor. We now travel about a half hour just to eat Joe’s pizza and it never disappoints. Perfect slices, doesn’t flop, great flavor.

I picked up a Grandma's pizza - which was amazing as always. Here is my question - the total for our order was $21.19 - which makes sense - $19.99 + tax. But when I look at my bank account it is $22.04 that was debited. Are you charging a convenience fee for using a card? The receipt I was given got soaked in the rain on the way out - so I tossed it without looking first - so no help there. I know it's only $.85 but I just want to know what the discrepancy is. **Update - answered promptly by the owner! I just missed the sign for the convenience fee! Sounds good - next time cash it is! :) Either way - nothing is stopping me from that Grandma's Pizza!!!!!

This is a pizzaria where you will enjoy dining in. The esthetics of this place are incredible. I am from Brooklyn, and i have never seen anything like it. All pictures, props, and newspapers on the walls and ceilings perfectly represent New York City and italian boroughs, the greatest city of the past. Pizza, ironically, is nothing like brooklyn Pizza now. It's much better. It tastes the true authentic Brooklyn pizza from the early 90s and 2000s. Not too greasy, not too dry. The owner Joe, a real New York Italian guy, a solid character who knows what he's doing. NYC is no good anymore. It's a dangerous swamp, but this place will give nostalgia. It's a reminder of what it used to be. Pizza in NY is very expensive and not authentic anymore. This place has affordable pizza with authenticity to it. To feel a piece of good Brooklyn, come to this place.

What a great find! We needed to drive over an hour to pick up an automotive part near here and since it was time for dinner I googled restaurants near me. Other bars and restaurants didn't have any good salads on the menu and everything was fried which doesn't agree with me so I kept searching. Brooklyn Pizza popped up and I'm so glad it did. It smells heavenly from the moment you walk in. They have a full staff in the kitchen, pizza slices ready to heat, eat, and go, and lots of salad options and other Italian specialties. It's busy with dine in and takeout just like our fav. Italian restaurant at home. So yummy. Love the ranch dressing for the really good salad. They are very accommodating as I added chicken to the broccoli pizza and asked for romaine lettuce instead of the iceberg mix. Thank you Brooklyn Pizza team for great food and service. Wish I lived closer.

The staff were friendly, great prices and the grandma pizza was absolutely delicious. We will 100% be recommending and returning!

1st time. Owner, staff friendly. Guided us through process of ordering. Food came quickly. Made with fresh ingredients. In my top 5 best pizza. Tried 2 of the desserts, both excellent.

Stopped by for dinner on a very busy Saturday night (our first two sit-down restaurant options were already super crowded) while in town for a performance nearby. Parking was impossible (lots of orders being picked up) for my large SUV, so I parked on the side street. We seated ourselves and went to the counter to order. My daughters got plain pizza and meat lovers’ slices. One got a cheeseburger. I am on an eating plan, so no refined carbs for me, so I ordered the BBQ chicken salad. All of our orders were out in a timely fashion and correct (requested no mayo on burger). My salad was amazing! Super fresh greens, delicious chicken (I should have asked for double the chicken, as my plan requires 4-6 oz per meal.), and even decorative curls of fresh carrot. The irony is that a mom and pop cafe couldn’t accommodate my dietary needs that earlier that day, but a PIZZA place menu could! Decor is typical of the pizza joints near us in Jersey. Owner waited on us himself, and he was very friendly and polite. He made in error in ringing us up, figured it out quickly, and re-rang it. Told him to keep the change, and he shook his head no and gave me all of the change and told me to just put a few bucks in the tip jar. $42 for four people - three large fountain drinks, a bottle of water, four slices (two plain, two meat lovers), a cheeseburger, and a large salad. That is a great value! Pizza is pretty similar to what we get in South Jersey from our local Italian-owned places. We would definitely stop by again when in the area.

The Grandma Pizza was incredible. First timer, but this has to be among the best pies in Lancaster. Note: this did not come Pac-Man shaped.