Blue Point Diner - American restaurant in Blue Point - 145 Montauk Hwy, USA

This place is a Blue Point Treasure. The food is spectacular, especially the homemade corned beef Hash. The owner talks to his customers, the wait staff is very friendly. Highly recommend and I'll definitely come back to try the dinner specials. Came back for dinner and the Beef Goulash was out of this World.

Come on … probably the best diner food on Long Island! This Long Island girl knows her diners. Heidi is the nicest and fastest waitress. Amazing homemade soups, bread pudding. Hubby raved about the patty melt. I enjoyed the feta spinach omelet with homemade home fries. Don’t miss this place. Charming and delicious. An LI slice of history.

Imagine you are in a little diner. This is your first time there. The most expensive sandwich on the menu is 17 dollars. You want a hero with 2 slices of turkey, scrambled eggs, 2 slices of tomato and 2 slices of cheese. with a cup of tea. Guess how many dollars you pay for the bill? $32.60 I was really shocked. When I told them that the bill was expensive, they told "you randomly created a sandwich" and I was handed a bill to sign in a hurry. It was really a terrible experience. When you go here make sure you ask them what you will pay at the end of the day so you don't get ripped off? If you hadn't ripped me off I would have recommended you to many of my friends and would visit you again. You gave up 100-150 dollars of future income to make 10-15 dollars more. A perfect business mentality. I would never recommend a business with this mentality.

loved it here!!! my husband got the spanish omelette & i got the mushroom omelette - both were awesome. came with a lot of toast (nicely buttered) & we ordered a side of bacon that was perfect!! the owner gave us some vegetable soup to try when we got home, i will be back for more!!! best vegetable soup i’ve ever had. will definitely be revisiting.

Food was decent and tasty. Could have had a bit more on the plate for the price. Service was okay. Just the basic required attentiveness given. Atmosphere was very dated. It needs a MAJOR remodeling. Felt a little offputting to us.

The quality of food is bad and overpriced. Be carreful with sides, not good and they costs like another meal.

Was the only meal I had that day, Greek salad with grilled chicken. It made me feel unsettled, quesey all afternoon. The queseyness lasted until I made it home. What followed was two days of the runs. My wife said I should have called Suffolk County Health Department.

Fantastic locally owned and operated diner! Great food and menu. The staff and owner are very friendly if you take the time to engage them. Great place and staff!