Blue Moon - Italian restaurant in Rockville Centre - 26 N Park Ave, USA

This is a local gem, and our server(Josh?) did not steer us wrong. We used to dine at Blue Moon years ago, before we moved, and decided to dine here Friday 10/6/2023. It was after 9:00 pm and the staff was welcoming and attentive. The 3 different types of complimentary bread, baked clams, Striped Bass special, Tiramisu dessert, and cappuccino were delicious. The entrée was large enough to share with my husband, and pictured are the specials menu, leftover Striped Bass entree, and half of the dessert. We highly recommend Blue Moon and will definitely return at our next visit to New York. Thank you for an excellent dining experience!

For the past 18 years, Blue Moon has been my go-to spot for delicious Italian food, and it continues to hold a special place in my heart. One dish that has never failed to impress me is their mouthwatering Meatball Pizza. The combination of flavorful soft meatballs, gooey good quality mozzarella cheese and perfectly baked crust ; top with a little oregano , parm cheese and hot flakes is simple irresistible to me. To enhance the dining experience, I highly recommend pairing the Meatball Pizza with either a rich red wine or a refreshing Blue Moon beer. The robust flavors of the red wine complement the savory meatballs and bring out the best in every bite. Alternatively, the crisp and citrusy notes of a Blue Moon beer provide a delightful contrast that cuts through the richness of the pizza, creating a harmonious balance of flavors. Thank you for remaining consistent with quality and taste of your Meatball Pizza.

I have passed this quaint restaurant many times but just never had an opportunity dine here. It was sure worth the wait. The staff is attentive, polite, and swift in the order taking and delivery of our food. We enjoyed two paninis for lunch. The grilled veggies and chicken cutlet paninis were cooked to perfection. The bread had nice flavor and a good crust. The fillings were ample and accompanied by a yummy sauce served on the side. A great spot for lunch and from the black board specials, we shall visit for dinner very soon.

Had lunch today in Blue Moon. The food was good but let me tell you the Chicken Parm hero was outstanding! Brandon our waiter was great as well as his co-worker Erica! Will definitely be back & a total recommend for everyone! 👍

The food was excellent. The coal fired pizza was one of the best I've ever had and I consider myself a pizza gourmet. The waiter was very knowledgeable and very personable . Pricing was moderate.

Food (The Cecilian Pizza) was extremely delicious. Staff were very polite and helpful during the meal and both the place and bathrooms were clean, would definitely come again

Was actually looking forward to this with all the good reviews. Ordered a large pepperoni for 38 on seamless yesterday, just to get a undercooked, soggy pie with watery sauce. Only decent and cooked part was the crust. Either way save your money find a different spot for pizza night.

Awesome dinner @bluemoonpizzeria , first time here, will be back...so delicious from the baked clams, house salad & coal fired pizza- half meatball/ half onions & black olives.... everything was tasty, delicious and Chris our server was amazing...great food , great service... great call @flawlessfaceslb .. #meecheatsny #bluemoonpizzeria #foodpics #foodiepics #rockvillecentreny #longislandnyeats #longislandnyfoodie