Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer - 35th St - American restaurant in New York - 45 W 35th St, USA

Ordered fried pickles, chicken sandwich, and Mexico burger. And a Oreo milkshake. I upgraded my fries to spicy fries. All the choices were delicious. The fried pickles were so good to start with, and they paired well with the Bronx IPA draft. Then the sandwiches showed up. Both were perfect. The burger with the pickled jalapeños hit the spot. The chicken was so good and crispy. The milk shake was unbelievable! Highly recommend this place! Great location and atmosphere.

Was here 3 weeks ago for my child's birthday dinner. My party was a little late for our reservations and when I called to let them know we was running late they were understanding. The food was okay and the milkshakes were really good. The service was okay. Our first server shift was over before we got our food he forgot to bring stuff we requested to the table and our new server was decent. Overall my child was happy and I would return.

On most days you will need a reservation to dine here. When we first sat down and had some water and ordered our food, a guy came up to us and asked if we had a reservation (we did). He couldn’t find the reservation in their system even though we did everything correctly and made us stand up and wait again, some of us were inside while most were outside. Then he said he will see what he can do about the situation. Luckily we got a table in the back and it actually worked out since it was way less people and quieter. Still, we were ready to leave when that happened. After this the experience became better. The food was delicious and the milkshakes are great.

The Greg Norman is fantastic. Added the Nashville Hot Fries, so tasty!. Crispy Chicken Sandwich was finger licking good. The Cookies 'n Cream Supreme milkshake speaks for itself!

Great burgers! I had the wagyu steakhouse burger and it was so juicy and delicious. Fries were cooked perfectly. Also had the Halloween special shake which was not the best but I'm not the biggest fan of chocolate that isn't a chocolate bar. I would definitely go back to try other shakes and burgers for that matter. Server was great when we ordered but after our meals were brought by someone else he never checked in with us. We had to call him for the check. However, this wouldn't dissuade us from going back.

3.5 Stars Our experience was on the mediocre side. It wasn't horrible but it wasn't outstanding either. There were highs and lows. Three of us went on a very rainy Friday evening after work and got there about 6:20ish. We originally wanted to make reservations. However we weren't able to because the times between 5 and 7:15 weren't available. Not blacked out as if unavailable but not listed at all. Then we called and were told we couldn't make reservations during that time slot so we just decided to walk in. When we got there we were asked if we had reservations... HOW?! If we're not able to make any how would we have reservations?? Well we put our names down and were told it would be a 45 min wait. So we sat at the bar and decided to start off while waiting. We had to wait a little but not too too long. We started with drinks and mozzarella sticks. The drinks were really good but they were out of all of the slushy drinks. We put in the order for the Mozzy sticks and in the midst of waiting for them our table was ready way quicker than we thought it would take because it was only about a 20 min wait so they brought the order over to our table. We did end up having to close out our bar order first though and do a separate order at the table. No big deal though. The Mozzy sticks were very very good! We tore those up! And that's not just because we were hungry. Unfortunately, we ended up having to do more cleaning to our table because it was still a bit of residue on it. I had to clean my seat because it looked like they just wiped everything from the table on to the seats. The guy who seemed like maybe a table clearer seemed more in tune with our table than our designated waitress. She was polite enough but like she couldn't be bothered one way or another. She was probably most interactive towards the end when handing us our check. Then when taking our orders I specifically told her no tomato because of an allergy. She said she would write it down to make sure. When I got my burger there was tomato on it and then when I reminded her we saw them take it off the plate, leave the lettuce, etc. so whatever it touched I couldn't eat. I didn't even bother asking for it to be made over because at that point I was over it. The burger I got which was the specialty burger was supposed to be well done because my friend asked for medium Greg Newman and hers was rare. Well mine was still pretty medium rare so I left it to just cook at home. It was also so unseasoned. I mean bland as idk what. I realized at home it was inedible so I ended up tossing it. The Caesar salad was good and came out fine. We came for the shakes so initially I was going to have a shake there and then take two classics to go but after the experience I decided to just get the shake there. That's when she decided to take my order. She took my friends order and walked away. In all fairness she asked was there anything else but we all understood it to mean did that particular person want anything else, not if the entire table wanted anything else. My other friend decided to not get anything at all after that. Eventually I got the cookies and cream shake and my friend had ordered the strawberry shortcake milkshake. We both enjoyed some there and took the rest to go. I didn't get the other shakes as initially intended and we asked for water but it took awhile to come so when it finally came we didn't even get any because that's when the check came and by that point we were getting ready to go and just wanted to pay. It was an interesting experience. Maybe they were overwhelmed on that day, I'm not sure. I would say this is definitely a step up from going to the old location in the 50's and leaving right out. However it's a step down from the service received when we went to the location further down in the city. I'd come back but I'd try something else and see how a different day works out. I do like the location way more though. It seems to be more spacious.

Steakhouse waygu was great! 9/10, would be 10/10 if patty had a little more seasoning. But overall a top tier burger! Fries, shakes, queso & Brussels were also good. Only downside was that we were seated in the back with these cloth chairs that were gross and not clean.

I got the pickle chips and the wagyu steakhouse burger with bacon. It was a good burger, but overall a heavy meal. The pickle chips are fried with a thicker batter which made them hard to finish. The wagyu burger was juicy, I liked the crispy onions. I’m glad the A1 sauce was served on the side. $26 dollars for this was a bit steep in my opinion, though it had bacon (also standard). The fries were decently crispy too. I wouldn’t come back, not because it wasn’t a good burger but it was a fairly forgettable dining experience.