Bettini Restaurant - Restaurant in Edgartown - Harbor View Hotel, 131 N Water St, USA

Beautiful ambiance, view of the Edgartown lighthouse and water, and great service, but bland entrees. We enjoyed our drinks (Derby cocktail and blueberry mule mocktail), and stuffed clams, but the swordfish and halibut entrees were so bland. Even the risotto that came with the swordfish were bland. It’s not just lack of salt but general lack of flavor. I’m confused because the menu states that the food is tested rigorously before being added to menus.

A great dining experience for those on the Vineyard who want something more formal and not seafood obsessive. I appreciated the variety of options on the menu and the wine/cocktail selection. A perfect date night.

A nice dining experience in the Harbor View Hotel. Pleasant staff and food is presented aesthetically. The food is good, but not great. Honestly, the specialty salad with blackberries was pretty, but it didn’t have much flavor. The vinaigrette was lacking and dulled the whole salad. The fava bean and mushroom pappardelle was just okay, but my husband’s swordfish was good. All in all, it is pretty in there and the staff will treat you well, but for someone who loves food and flavors, it just wasn’t outstanding. It seems you are paying more for the country club type atmosphere and location rather than terrific cuisine.

Our waitress, Cassidy, made our wonderful breakfast especially enjoyable. She was very attentive and friendly, sharing her personal experiences with us, which made our breakfast even better than expected by her engaging and caring personality. We so appreciated all that she had to share, which helped us make decisions about some upcoming family plans. Though breakfast is expensive here, everything is fresh, delicious, and plentiful, whole the service takes your meal to another level. Upscale dining meets a comfort level you can enjoy without excessive stuffiness. And the view can’t be beat!

My husband and I would like to thank Bettini Restaurant for a very special wedding anniversary dinner! 😊❤️🎉 The food was more than delicious, and the service truly was the best we've ever had. Our waitress was so attentive to our needs, and the manager came over several times to see how things were going. We both couldn't have been happier with our experience! I highly recommend it! See my photos for the incredibly special way they helped us celebrate our 5th anniversary!

We each had fabulous dinners. The carpaccio was superb. Excellent crab cake. Beautiful and tasty foie gras by James. Thank you for attentive service Seal. The crème brûlée was perfection.

Fantastic service. Thank you to our wonderful server, Giulia! Fantastic food. Great quality and perfectly cooked meat. Absolutely amazing cocktails and wine options. We will most certainly be back very soon!

We had one of the best meals on the island here! Caroline was our server and not only suggested an excellent dish but was attentive and kind. The view is perfect for sunset and every dish we tried was cooked to perfection. Definitely a must try!