Bagel Train - Bagel shop in Suffern - 150 Orange Ave, USA

The Bagel Train experience, as I call it is definitely One of a Kind!!! I have been buying bagels and coffee here 25 years now and it’s a Family Tradition like no other to visit this glorious place at least once a while and get the heavenly foods there. I am not exaggerating but their bagels are the BEST you will ever have! Today my experience was even more amazing, as I ordered the famous bagel sticks, which they do not have every day and they are only available upon prior order. I waited an hour to pick up what I considerer the most satisfying food ever❤️ These super hot, straight from the oven god’s creations were beyond delicious and satisfying! I surprised my family with an amazing breakfast and again this one of a kind experience. I thank the owners of Bagel Train for never changing their recipes and for making thousands of people happy each month with their amazing foods. SIMPLY ICONIC SPOT.

The bagels are consistently the best around. You can’t go wrong choosing Bagel Train, but recently I picked up multiple bagels to bring to share and decided to also purchase their butter and cream cheese. When I bought the cream cheese, it looked normal on the outside, but when I got to work and opened it, it was moldy.

Why this place doesn’t have a full 5 star rating, I will never know. The bagels are the BEST I’ve ever had, freshly made every day. The small shop adds to the quaintness

i ordered a toasted everything bagel turkey bacon egg and cheese, eggs scrambled soft. it wasnt toasted, the egg was grossly over cooked, and there was no cheese at all. worst of all and what made me write a review at all was that i found a piece of pork bacon in my sandwich. I do not eat any pork for personal/ethical reasons and the taste of it makes me sick. this was honestly it for me and I will not be returning. hope y’all have better luck than i did

Literally the best bagel place around. Always fresh. The actual shop is small and can get extremely crowded with long lines. But totally worth the wait. Staff is super friendly. 5/5 and highly recommend! (Whether it’s Taylor ham and cheese, scallion cream cheese, lox, etc… never a bad experience).

Best bagels around. They are huge, fresh, and warm. Sandwiches are a good size. The service is fast, friendly and helpful. Used to live locally now, we hit it after every family visit to pick up a dozen and sandwiches for the ride home.

Layout/atmosphere *Across the street from Metro North train line; takeout only; parking lot Food/drink *Everything bagel with cream cheese - Good

The bagels are ok, but everything seemed to be a bit too done. I like my bagels toasted if they aren't directly from the oven and still hot, the outside wasn't too dark but toasting it made it super crunchy - and not like what you'd typically expect from toasting a bagel. The bacon was almost burnt and a bit too salty, and the hash browns were almost burnt as well. The cinnamon twist was good as is, but I think it would be even better if it was warm. It also weighed a ton, so it's a very substantial pastry. I enjoyed watching them boil, season, and then bake the bagels right behind the counter! They were filling up the bins straight from the oven and if they hadn't been so busy I would have gotten back in line to try a fresh, warm bagel. I'll definitely go back and give it another try because I've heard great things about their bagels.