Anthony's Pizzeria Warren - Pizza restaurant in Warren - 26150 Schoenherr Rd, USA

We were craving a Chicago Style pizza the night we ordered and after hunting on the internet, we found Anthony's. Unfortunately, it was okay, nothing to write home about. It was our first time here. The staff was very friendly and polite on the phone and in person. The place wasn't very hard to find. The pizza was ready on time and it was made correctly but that was about all I can say that we liked about it. We ordered a 'Chicago' Style pizza with mushrooms, onions, sausage, and pepperoni as well as a large round sausage. First, I say 'Chicago' because this wasn't a true Chicago style pizza. This pizza was more like a round Detroit style pizza because there wasn't a top crust, just a bottom crust, toppings, cheese, and sauce. Next, their signature sauce tasted overly sweet; this wasn't just the opinion of 1 but 3 adults and the 3 kids said it tasted off (probably the sweetest). Overall, everyone has their own taste. Don't let this review stop you from trying them. You may love them like other reviewers have or you may not. They're just not for us. They've been in business for a long time so they must be doing something right!

Anthony's Pizzeria offers a delightful dining experience. The pizza is consistently delicious with a perfect crust-to-topping ratio. The menu is diverse, featuring tasty pasta dishes and flavorful appetizers. The service is friendly and efficient, creating a welcoming atmosphere. Anthony's Pizzeria is a top choice for satisfying your Italian cravings in Warren.

Customer service was good on the phone and in person. It did take about 45 mns for my pizza to be done, which is a long time. I ordered a large square deepdish veggie pizza with anchovies welldone with a side of ranch. Notice two of the pics i uploaded show the amount of oil in this pizza. The cardboard became so soggy that not only is my car going to smell like pizza with anchovies for the next few days, but it seemed like the cardboard was going to fall apart. That by itself to be honest is minus 1 star. Would be 2 but the other star is subtracted because the pizza was a bit tooooooo moist and soft other than the well enjoyed crispy crust, although I asked for welldone and waited a long long time. The ingredients tasted great. The anchovies tasted very flavorfull and pretty powerfull. I always order anchovies on pizza as often as I can, and this one is gooood. The ranch was nice and creamy. I would recommend this pizza and I will give them another chance one day. Just make sure to tell them to put a sheet under the pizza so your car and dining table dont become oily.

Order from here multiple times a week! Our favorite pizza place and George and Ron make you feel like family; I don’t even give my name when I order anymore lol. I tell everyone to try this place!

This was my first pizza from Anthony's. XXL large (The New Yorker). Bacon, Onion and Pepperoni. It was a really good pizza. Good cheese, lots of toppings and awesome sauce. The person who took my order was incredibly friendly. I will definitly be ordering from here again.

I have lived on the next street since I was 4. My best friend an I were one of/if not their very first customers. They were giving out sample slices I think I must have been maybe 13? 14? I would rather have their pizza over anyone else. They do a great job, they are kind and courteous and a staple of the community. Thanks for all the incredible meals you have provided us.

We've been getting our take out pizza from Anthony's forever! The owner's really nice and the pizza's delicious ! We love the old fashioned pepperoni. I also love their subs! The flat bread is great and the subs are amazing.

We tried this pizza place for the first time, and it was amazing dude’s named Anthony can always make pizza lol 😆 🍕