Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Pizza restaurant in Altamonte Springs - 420 E Altamonte Dr #1020, USA

Not a bad place for a Pizza. Our server, Dakota, was friendly and attentive. Pizza was hot, and we had more than enough to take home. Sangria & wings were good too!

This was such a great place to eat pizza, to be honest the best in orlando in my opinion, but now they are ridiculous with portions. I always order prosciutto pizza but never had just one slice of prosciutto divided to the entire pizza like today. This was my last time here for sure.

I've always wanted to try Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza. I went on their website to order and it stated that once you downloaded the app you get a 12 inch pizza for free. Since I've never tried them before I decided to take advantage and go the free route. Got a basic cheese pizza cause that's the only pizza my 4 year old likes. As you can tell from the photos the pizza was burnt. I've never ordered a pizza whether it is from papa johns, Pizza Hut etc and the pizza is so badly burnt. It was 6 slices and we got about 3 ok slices out of it. And by ok I mean they were still burnt but not as burnt and hard as the others. I don't know if I would order from them again or just simply try a different location and I say that because right at the tip of the pizza, that first bite few bites the pizza wasn't awful tasting. I give this location the side eye because it was obvious that they spoiled the pizza and didn't give us a different one. I looked into the box after exiting the plaza plus I had my daughter and couldn't bother with the hassle of turning back plus waiting for another pizza. It was free so I was like thank God I didn't spend money on this because if I did rest assured I would have turned back. Maybe because it was free they didn't care to change it like they probably have would if I was a pay customer. Either way it shouldn't matter.

Come on guys, You really have to listen to your paying customer requests. I placed an order online and called directly after requesting that my pizza not have globs of sauce on top of the cheese. I do not like sauce on top, it belongs under the cheese. I pick up my pie only to discover the globs of sauce on my pizza. This happens too frequent. Please start listening.

Gina was great, and the food was amazing. Visited Anthony's in Woodbury, NY, and it was great, we didn't realize there was a local one. After shopping, we opted for a visit, got the Caprese salad, and the Carnivori pie, both were phenomenal. Definitely make your way there!

So don’t order wings here, we were seated over by the brick ovens and we noticed a bakers rack of what looked like chicken wings over there. We didn’t pay any attention but after 30 minutes that same rack was there, we had ordered buffalo wings and they arrived but they were pretty dry. I proceeded to ask the waitress if those were wings on that rack and if ours were made from that same batch and that they were sitting there since we’ve arrived her response? “Oh no your wings were made from a batch this morning.” Okay A) why can’t my wings be made to order. B) I feel bad for who got those wings cause they sat out for all that time. After I made that comment someone from the kitchen proceeded to pull the bakers rack back inside behind the kitchen doors.

My husband and I were looking for coal fired pizza and this is the place! Really enjoyed a 12” traditional pizza with gluten free crust cooked to perfection. Just the right balance of mozzarella and crushed tomatoes on a crispy thin crust. My husband chose the traditional pizza and coal fired regular crust. Half was topped with long hots. He said it was fantastic. Service was friendly and efficient. An additional plus: you can receive a free 12” pizza on next visit for scanning barcode and signing up for emails. Atmosphere was a little dark for us so we sat closer to the front windows. Nice experience all the way around.

I was looking for a pizzeria to take my family to, not a sports bar! Not a too loud disco! not a fast food restaurant, with hard seats! that are WAY TO uncomfortable. I miss pizza inn. And no vegetable pizza on the menu. If the drink selections are better than the pizza selection then you're a bar.