Anchor Inn Boutique Hotel - Hotel in Put-In-Bay - 500 Catawba Ave, USA

From check in to check out this place was 5 stars. So beautiful and so clean. The State Room (the room we stayed in) was so comfortable and the deck facing town just added to the already amazing room. The bed was so comfy. The bathroom was huge . And out of sight there is a mini fridge with cold water in it, a coffee maker with pods and creamer, and safe to use if needed. And you can also find fresh coffee down in the lobby every morning along with fresh fruit, bagels, etc. The breakfast menu has so many options and the choices my husband and I made each morning were delicious. And last but not least, the owner cares about his guests and making their stay the best ever. We are already looking forward to our next stay.

Had a wonderful stay over Labor Day weekend! The 3rd floor rooms were comfortable and spacious. Being a busy holiday weekend the Inn is close enough to walk around but yet at night the balcony was enjoyable and peaceful. Couldn’t hear any of the night noise in the rooms. The selection of breakfast foods was amazing every morning. The staff was polite and accommodating. Wouldn’t hesitate to stay there again.

We stayed in the State Room at The Anchor Inn Boutique Hotel at Put-in-Bay over Labor Day weekend. We had such a great experience while we were there. The Inn is such a charming and beautiful place to stay. It was nice to have a safe and quiet side of the island to go back and relax for the night. We enjoyed the peaceful mornings having coffee on our porch, and then having a delicious breakfast made for us by the owner Paul Easterling. He is quite the talented chef adding a unique touch to his breakfast specials. Both he and his wife Emily are very warm and welcoming, and make you feel at home during your stay. I highly recommend staying here for a night or a weekend. We will be coming back next year!

This was our first stay in Put In Bay. We couldn’t have selected a nicer place to stay. The owners are down to earth and friendly! . The staff also were extremely polite and friendly! The room was beautiful and very clean! They have nice little extras like Qtips, make up remover towels and robes. They also include breakfast which was absolutely delicious! The omelets were phenomenal!! We will definitely be staying here the next time we plan to come to the island. Terry and Linda

This place is a gem. Great location within walking distance to town and all restaurants, bars etc. If you’d like to explore further and rent a golf cart, the Golf Cart Depot is right across the street. Our family of 5 (3 adult children) stayed in the Wee Anchor Cottage, which had plenty of room. The service was great and the breakfast is spectacular - made to order by Chef Paul. And the menu is impressive- the chilaquiles and Dutch Baby were my favorites. Will definitely return!

Amazing room. Loved the coziness and cleanliness. Paul the owner was amazing and took great care of us. Breakfast was included and was phenomenal. When we go back to put in bay, there’s nowhere else we will stay. ❤️❤️❤️

Anchor Inn Hotel is in a league of its own. From the staff, the amenities and the overall feel of the place is excellent. They do all the little things well, the rooms are bigger than you think they are and its a diamond in the rough on the island of Put N Bay. My wife and I were surprised by everything and if we ever come back to the island, the only place we will stay is at the Anchor Inn.

What a great find on this little island. Definitely for grown ups. The place is beautiful and the owner’s hospitality is wonderful. Their First Mate’s suite is on the third floor with a balcony that overlooks the quiet street and all the flowers planted here. Very pretty and serene. The bed was so comfortable. Breakfast served is very tasty and they offer quite a bit on their menu as well as self serving. Staff were very pleasant and kind. They have a dumbwaiter to take your luggage to the third floor which was very convenient. We could walk to a very fine dining restaurant Goat Soup and Whiskey. Open for lunch and dinner. Five star B&B for sure! We were there on a Wednesday and Thursday. Island was not crowded, yet!