A Round Pizza - Restaurant in Cortland - 4943 NY-281, USA

Always a 10/10! The best pizza in the area. Worth the 45 minutes drive each way for us. Will continue to recommend it to everyone!

While it's hard to compete with the char grilled wing spots in town. They serve the best boneless wings hands down. Massive pieces with super crunchy exterior. No contest

I ordered a small cheese pizza for my 5 1/2 year old daughter on Saturday 11/04/2023 while traveling through that area. It was the worse pizza I have ever order. My daughter has stomach virus that night and she was sick for 4/5 days. Please don’t order from there if you have small kid. I feel sorry for the business owner who run a pizza shop like that.

There is nothing cozy or flashy about this establishment, nor does there need to be; they make very good pizza at prices that are by today's standards normal. I think it's the best carryout pizza in town.

I ordered an 18inch chicken bacon ranch pizza and it was cold,and I ordered 20 wings that were over done. I've ordered here many times and it was never like this. I can't say if I'll go back or not,once bitten twice shy as they say. Hopefully they will read this and make it right. And I picked up on time.

Good pizza! When I ordered tonight at 7pm they told me they were closing soon when I requested they have the pizza ready for pickup at 730, very annoying and clearly lazy employees trying to close quickly

We are staying at Hope Lake Lodge (at Greek Peak) and decided to stay in our first night after a day of traveling. When comparing reviews from the other three restaurants that deliver here A Round Pizza was a no-brainer. We ordered two medium pizzas and two Greek salads. As you can see from the pictures, they are very generous with toppings and their portions (both pizza and salad) are quite large! They didn’t have Greek dressing which I thought was odd, but I ended up using their Caesar which actually went well with my salad. There were huge chunks of feta and lettuce that had not been broken down which was more of a nuisance than anything. However, they used black olives over kalamata which technically isn’t a Greek salad. Also, the crust was a little dry. However, A Round Pizza was a pleasant treat after a long day and we would certainly order again the next time we stay at this resort. Oh, and for anyone staying here the minimum order for delivery is $50. When you compare prices at the resort restaurants this minimum is nothing and well worth it!

Have you ever had A Round Pizza? I was asked this question by my daughter and I immediately answered of course, not realizing she meant the pizza shop named "A Round Pizza". Well Joe serves a great slice of pizza with a thinner crust, much like typical NYC slices. The right amount of sauce and great tasting toppings, including mozzarella that's not too oily, makes this a great spot to pick up an entire pie or try their daily specials (2 slices and drink $6.50).